A personal finance app connects your bank, card and investment accounts and turns every transaction into a few numbers: what you earned, what you spent and what you saved. Before it does anything else, it has to get those numbers right. Transfers between your own accounts and credit card payments stay out of spending. Refunds and money friends pay you back come off the purchase they were for instead of counting as income. And a savings rate only means something when the app can see your income. Budgets, charts and forecasts are all built on these totals, so if the totals are off, so is everything built on them.
Below, each one with numbers, then one month counted two ways and a few checks to run on any app.
What a personal finance app is for
Many apps can show you a list of purchases sorted into categories. A personal finance app is meant to give you the whole picture: money in, money out, money set aside, and how the month is going. That makes it less forgiving of small mistakes. One transfer counted as spending throws off your spending, your income and your savings rate at the same time.
If you mostly want to keep track of costs you share with a partner or roommates, our post on apps to track expenses when you share costs covers that. This one is about the whole picture.
Transfers between your own accounts aren't spending
Say you move $500 from checking to savings. Your checking account shows $500 going out. Your savings account shows $500 coming in. If the app treats every dollar out as spending and every dollar in as income, that one move adds $500 to your spending and $500 to your income, and you did neither.
The same goes for moving money into a brokerage or retirement account. The money is still yours, in a different account. A good app pairs the two sides of the move and leaves both out of spending and income. Money moved into savings or investments still matters, though: it's what you saved, which comes up again below.
Credit card payments aren't spending either
The spending happened when you used the card. Paying the bill later moves money from checking to the card company to clear what you already spent. Say you put $1,100 on a card in a month and pay the $1,100 statement from checking. If the payment counts as spending, that month looks like $2,200 of purchases. If the credit arriving on the card counts as income, your income jumps by $1,100 too.
Card payments show up under many descriptions, so an app that looks for one phrase will miss some. Our post on a budget app that doesn't count credit card payments goes through the double count in detail and how to fix it in any app or spreadsheet.
Paybacks and refunds lower the purchase
You pay a $200 dinner for four people on your card. Your share is $50. Over the next week, your friends send you $150. The $150 settles what your friends owed for the dinner, so your dining for the month is $50 and your income doesn't change.
A refund works the same way. You buy a $100 jacket, return part of the order and get $40 back. You spent $60 on clothes, and the $40 comes off the jacket.
There's one trap here. If you already split the dinner in Splitwise and the app counts only your $50 share, the $150 payback settles the debt and nothing more. It should not lower the dinner a second time, which would leave your dining at minus $100. Each payback should reduce the purchase once.
Income should mean money you earned
Income is your pay: paychecks, freelance work, a bonus. Many deposits look like income and aren't: a card payment credit, a transfer from your own savings, a friend's payback, a refund. Counting all of them makes your income look higher than it is, and any rate built on it looks lower.
A good app recognizes a paycheck from its pattern, such as the same employer, a similar amount and a steady schedule (every two weeks, twice a month or monthly). When a deposit is unclear, it's better for the app to ask you than to file it as income.
A savings rate needs income data
Savings rate is the money you set aside divided by your income:
(cash saved + investment contributions) ÷ income
Say your take-home pay is $4,000 a month, in two paychecks of $2,000. You move $400 to savings and $300 to a brokerage account. You saved $700, and your savings rate is $700 ÷ $4,000, or 17.5%.
Now say the app only sees one of the two paychecks, because one goes to an account you haven't connected. Your savings rate shows $700 ÷ $2,000, or 35%. If it sees no paycheck at all, there is nothing to divide by. Some apps show 0% in that case, which reads as "you saved nothing" when you saved $700. A better answer is to show the $700 and say the rate is waiting on income data.
One month, counted two ways
Here is a single month with all of the above:
- two paychecks of $2,000 each
- rent of $1,800 from checking
- $1,100 of card purchases, including that $200 dinner
- the $1,100 card bill, paid in full from checking
- $150 from friends for the dinner
- $400 moved to savings and $300 to a brokerage account
Count every dollar out as spending and every dollar in as income, and you get:
- spending of $4,700: rent, card purchases, the card payment and both transfers
- income of $5,950: both paychecks, the paybacks, the card payment credit and both transfers arriving
Counted correctly:
- Spending is $1,800 of rent plus $1,100 of card purchases, minus the $150 of paybacks: $2,750.
- Income is the two paychecks: $4,000.
- Saved is $400 plus $300: $700, a savings rate of 17.5%.
- The rest, $550, stays in checking. You can check it: $4,000 + $150 − $1,800 − $1,100 − $400 − $300 = $550.
The first version is off by almost $2,000 on spending and on income, from the same transactions.
Checks to run on any app
You don't need a new app to test this. Pick a recent month you remember well and look at what your current app says.
- Find a transfer to savings. Your spending total shouldn't include it, and your income shouldn't either.
- Find a month you paid a big card bill. If income jumped by the bill amount, the card side of the payment is being counted.
- Find a dinner or trip friends paid you back for. The category should show your share, and the paybacks shouldn't appear in income.
- Add up your category totals. They should equal your spending total. If spending is higher, something without a category, often a card payment or transfer, is being counted.
- Look at your savings rate in a month where one paycheck went somewhere the app can't see. If the rate looks too good, or shows 0%, the app is working with missing income.
If an app fails one of these, you can usually fix it by hand by marking transactions as transfers. Check that the next sync doesn't undo your fix. A budget or a month-end forecast built on these totals is only as good as they are.
To see how several apps handle transfers, card payments and partners, our budgeting app comparison puts them side by side. Monio leaves transfers and card payments out of spending, takes refunds and paybacks off the purchase they were for, and says when income data is incomplete instead of showing a 0% savings rate.
Questions
What does a personal finance app do?
A personal finance app connects your bank, card and investment accounts and shows what you earned, what you spent and what you saved. To be useful, it has to leave transfers and card payments out of spending and take refunds and paybacks off the purchase they were for.
Should a transfer to savings count as spending?
No. Moving money from checking to savings or a brokerage account keeps it in your own accounts, so it isn't spending or income. It counts as money you saved.
Do refunds and paybacks count as income?
No. A refund or a friend's payback lowers the purchase it was for. A $200 dinner with $150 paid back by friends is $50 of dining and no income.
How do you calculate your savings rate?
Add the cash you saved and your investment contributions, then divide by your income. If you saved $700 on $4,000 of take-home pay, your savings rate is 17.5%. Without income data, the rate can't be worked out, and 0% would be wrong.